American Idol 7 Top 10 - Carly Smithson - Total Eclipse video free download

Brian Hagaman

I Loved The song she did well Don't listen to Randy and Simon there both Wrong 

DrNordo

She didn't even get the lyrics right. Average voice at best, as well. Off key, etc.

Paul Gilbert Ananayo

i thought i just saw Katniss Everdeen perform on stage... hihihi ;-)

Ma.rhodora Garcia

Wow!! Like it :) but o hate is if the lyrics are wrong :(

Jason Bouwman

Shes the lead singer of We Are The Fallen

John Ferguson

She's not bad (in fact, she's pretty good)...but she just doesn't have the voice for this song. It takes a special voice to pull off a Jim Steinman song, and she just does not have it. (And nice job of butchering a 7-minute masterpiece into a 2-minute abortion!)

Neto JON

oh comon, ok i loved her, but she would never, ever, ever ever, not in a million years become anything closee to celine dion... not because she is not good... but because celine is just so perfect, just whitney houston herself is better than celine... no other singer will ever come close, at least not anyone that exists right now

Jmoraes

Circumstance.

Renee Shiffler

I remember this. it seems like forever ago. when I actually enjoyed American Idol. I love her version of this! <3

Hadi Yazid

She is obviously has a strong voice but for her rendition of this song, the emotion wasn't expressed as good as Leah Michelle and Bonnie Tyler! It was an OK effort.

Erin Smithson

hee, my name's Erin Smithson! llllooooovvveee :D

thegorgeousgeeks

Not as good as the original. Bonnie Tyler had so much emotion in each line. I liked Diary of a Wimpy version better than this too.

Roddy Carnell

@randomnessjunk She is with "We are the Fallen" now

Ashton Pittman

@randomnessjunk The next Celine Dion? lol There is no 'next Celine Dion.' You mean the next Amy Lee wannabe?

koki cummings

@randomnessjunk are you joking no one is like celine dion

Deejay Johnstone

@1227mame Carly is literally the perfect size. She's the same size as Amy Lee and most of the other positive role models young girls should be looking up to. Maybe you ought to stop looking up to the wrong kind of people and learn not to be so rude.

GothicPaganGirl

She made it anyways :D She is a great singer for We Are The Fallen :)

demonhoopa

@1227mame Fat? That's weak dude. There's nothing wrong with the way this young lady looks.

squirtlemcgee

I don't the back up singers are bad, I just don't think their voices suited Carly's. I love this song and I think Carly rocked it. :)

Jerry Lindberg

just perfect imo

Carly Smithson

Carly Smithson - Alone (Hollywood Week)

Carly Smithson

Carly Smithson - I Drove All Night - Top 16

Carly Smithson

Carly Smithson - Blackbird - Top 11