Sara Lov

Interesting thing that happened with this song. Arcade fire puts out the original, and in my opinion, quote "my opinion" Peter Gabriele sings it the way it was meant to be sung. I know that's a counter intuitive comment because naturally It's an AF song, but I just feel it and hear it with this particular song, that it was meant for Peter Gabriele.

11 years назад

AllieLovesGingerAle

Anyone's got the piano sheet for this beautiful version?

12 years назад

ThePhoenixAvalon

This is a wonderful version and I think it's on par with Arcade Fire's. They both give a very different feel but retain the soul of the song.

12 years назад

explodingdock

@killerbumble well yeah, thats why it is a question of taste ;-) I do like both of them, even if your are right about the lyrics rather suiting to a more melancholic voice.

12 years назад

Jonah Drake

@explodingdock Same lyrics, out of place feel. The others had a hostile feel to it, and the lyrics and voice added to it. Sara's highly edited voice and the way the song sounds way to happy just doesn't work for me.

12 years назад

explodingdock

@killerbumble well still the same lyrics, right?! ;-) it spite of being a cover, I think one shouldnt always compare everything directly. I love arcade fire, but this version is also a very good!

12 years назад

Jonah Drake

@explodingdock Dude, the original version is 10x better. Even Peter's version was amazing. Too me, she sounds way too happy, while the others you can hear the pain in their voice.