Kelly Clarkson

Comments

8 years ago

Arsheen Virani

Omg I thought this song was a 1D original wth my life is a lie

9 years ago

Dyamond Sierra

omg I love

9 years ago

Krizel Cris

Bello...Bravissima....

9 years ago

amy96525

To everyone who thinks that One Direction is the the original 'artists' of this song, your sadly mistaken. Kelly Clarkson is, she didn't know if she should give 1D her song. She doesn't normally give away her songs like that, but she liked how they sang it, so she gave it to them. I have to admit though, both versions are amazing. I have nothing against One Direction.

9 years ago

erik koski

one direction fans I don't care what you say there's only one Kelly Clarkson one direction's a boyband they're a majority backstreet boys new kids on the block nsync and soooooooooooooooo many others

9 years ago

Jepsie JC

oh my gosh i thought "Tell Me A Lie" is a 1D creation....anyway Kelly version and 1D version are both amazing!

9 years ago

Jonathan Counce

why can't people spell "you're" correctly???

9 years ago

Ιωαννα μπολικα

I love kelly's version but let's be honest people...it's 2014 stop pretending that one direction sucks.

9 years ago

superdirectioner Horan Styles

explico, esta chica iba a sacar la canciones pero se la sesión a 1D convirtiéndola originalmente de ellos okay!?

9 years ago

Zehra Uzmen

TELL ME A LIE

9 years ago

andrea barbosa

honestly 1d is better IM 1D AF !11!1111! also Kelly didnt want this in her album cos she obviously didnt like how it sounded in her album. #EMAbiggestfans1D #vote5sos

9 years ago

Lauren Armstrong

I like this :) almost as good as the other version by my boys

9 years ago

Eden Stokes

both versions of this song are equally as good omg.

9 years ago

Magicfairyk Olmedo

If people knew a thing or two, this is the song she wrote FOR 1DAnd I'm in both fandoms, js

9 years ago

schlee0612

Half the people commenting on here probably haven't even heard One Direction's version. BECAUSE IT'S PRETTY MUCH THE SAME FREAKING THING. Stereotypical boyband my butt. Their first album was eh, but their most recent work is so beautiful. You go and try to hit Zayn Malik's note in You & I and then tell me it's not meaningful. Because you wouldn't work so hard to hit a note if the song didn't mean much to you.

9 years ago

Faith Thompson

People on here can say one direction doesnt care but they do just as much as kelly I have been with both of these artists from the beginning of their careers and im going to stay with them and stand up for them they both put meaning behind what they sing ENOUGH SAID

9 years ago

DreamASMR

The Queen! Kelly Clarkson <3 <3 <3

9 years ago

Hannah May

I love this song. Really wish she'd kept it for herself though

9 years ago

frederick saunders

men should listern to this song cos they don't listern all they care about is one thing and if they don't get it on to the next girl and fuck u off

9 years ago

Angelica Alaniz

All These 1D Comments Really Bug I Mean Yes They Sang It But Kelly Put Meaning Into It Unlike Some Boy Band That Sang It For Likes And Views And/Or Money Just Saying I Mean Idk Don't Get Me Wrong I Don't Hate 1D But There's A Lot More Variety Then Boy Bands Who Sell Music That Makes Girls Feel Special To Gain Money I Mean Kelly Sings From The Heart And That Makes An Artist c: